Previous studies by our laboratory have demonstrated that implanting a stiffer tissue engineered construct at surgery is positively correlated with repair tissue stiffness at 12 weeks. The objective of this study was to test this correlation by implanting a construct that matches normal tissue biomechanical properties. To do this, we utilized a soft tissue patellar tendon autograft to repair a central-third patellar tendon defect. Patellar tendon autograft repairs were contrasted against an unfilled defect repaired by natural healing (NH). We hypothesized that after 12 weeks, patellar tendon autograft repairs would have biomechanical properties superior to NH. Bilateral defects were established in the central-third patellar tendon of skeletally mature (one year old), female New Zealand White rabbits (n = 10). In one limb, the excised tissue, the patellar tendon autograft, was sutured into the defect site. In the contralateral limb, the defect was left empty (natural healing). After 12 weeks of recovery, the animals were euthanized and their limbs were dedicated to biomechanical (n = 7) or histological (n = 3) evaluations. Only stiffness was improved by treatment with patellar tendon autograft relative to natural healing (p = 0.009). Additionally, neither the patellar tendon autograft nor natural healing repairs regenerated a normal zonal insertion site between the tendon and bone. Immunohistochemical staining for collagen type II demonstrated that fibrocartilage-like tissue was regenerated at the tendon-bone interface for both repairs. However, the tissue was disorganized. Insufficient tissue integration at the tendon-to-bone junction led to repair tissue failure at the insertion site during testing. It is important to re-establish the tendon-to-bone insertion site because it provides joint stability and enables force transmission from muscle to tendon and subsequent loading of the tendon. Without loading, tendon mechanical properties deteriorate. Future studies by our laboratory will investigate potential strategies to improve patellar tendon autograft integration into bone using this model.
References
1.
Baer
, G. S.
, and Harner
C. D.
, 2007, “Clinical Outcomes of Allograft Versus Autograft in Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction
,” Clin. Sports Med.
, 26
(4
), pp. 661
–681
. 2.
Galatz
, L. M.
, Ball
, C. M.
, Teefey
, S. A.
, Middleton
, W. D.
, and Yamaguchi
K.
, 2004, “The Outcome and Repair Integrity of Completely Arthroscopically Repaired Large and Massive Rotator Cuff Tears
,” J. Bone Joint Surg.Series A
, 86
(2
), pp. 219
–224
.3.
Harryman
II, D. T.
, Mack
, L. A.
, Wang
, K. Y.
, Jackins
, S. E.
, Richardson
, M. L.
, and Matsen
III, F. A.
, 1991, “Repairs of the Rotator Cuff: Correlation of Functional Results With Integrity of the Cuff
,” J. Bone Joint Surg. Series A
, 73
(7
), pp. 982
–989
.4.
Lafosse
, L.
, Brozska
, R.
, Toussaint
, B.
, and Gobezie
, R.
, 2007, “The Outcome and Structural Integrity of Arthroscopic Rotator Cuff Repair With Use of the Double-Row Suture Anchor Technique
,” J. Bone Joint Surg. Series A
, 89
(7
), pp. 1533
–1541
. 5.
Leppilahti
, J.
, Puranen
, J.
, and Orava
S.
, 1996, “Incidence of Achilles Tendon Rupture
,” Acta. Orthop. Scand.
, 67
(3
), pp. 277
–279
. 6.
Strauss
, E. J.
, Ishak
, C.
, Jazrawi
, L.
, Sherman
, O.
, and Rosen
J.
, 2007, “Operative Treatment of Acute Achilles Tendon Ruptures: An Institutional Review of Clinical Outcomes
,” Injury
, 38
(7
), pp. 832
–838
. 7.
Safran
, M. R.
, and Harner
C. D.
, 1996, “Technical Considerations of Revision Anterior Cruciate Ligament Surgery
,” Clin. Orthop.
, 325
, pp. 50
–64
. 8.
Rodeo
, S. A.
, Potter
, H. G.
, Kawamura
, S.
, Turner
, A. S.
, Hyon
, J. K.
, and Atkinson
B. L.
, 2007, “Biologic Augmentation of Rotator Cuff Tendon-Healing With Use of a Mixture of Osteoinductive Growth Factors
,” J. Bone Joint Surg. Series A
, 89
(11
), pp. 2485
–2497
. 9.
Gulotta
, L. V.
, and Rodeo
S. A.
, 2009, “Growth Factors for Rotator Cuff Repair
,” Clin. Sports Med.
, 28
(1
), pp. 13
–23
. 10.
Kovacevic
, D.
, and Rodeo
S. A.
, 2008, “Biological Augmentation of Rotator Cuff Tendon Repair
,” Clin. Orthop.
, 466
(3
), pp. 622
–633
. 11.
Seeherman
, H. J.
, Archambault
, J. M.
, Rodeo
, S. A.
, Turner
, A. S.
, Zekas
, L.
, D’Augusta
, D.
, Li
, X. J.
, Smith
, E.
, and Wozney
, J. M.
, 2008, “rhBMP-12 Accelerates Healing of Rotator Cuff Repairs in a Sheep Model
,” J. Bone Joint Surg. Series A
, 90
(10
), pp. 2206
–2219
. 12.
Rodeo
, S. A.
, Suzuki
, K.
, Deng
, X.
, Wozney
, J.
, and Warren
R. F.
, 1999, “Use of Recombinant Human Bone Morphogenetic Protein-2 to Enhance Tendon Healing in a Bone Tunnel
,” Am. J. Sports Med.
, 27
(4
), pp. 476
–488
.13.
Derwin
, K. A.
, Baker
, A. R.
, Spragg
, R. K.
, Leigh
, D. R.
, and Iannotti
J. P.
, 2006, “Commercial Extracellular Matrix Scaffolds for Rotator Cuff Tendon Repair: Biomechanical, Biochemical, and Cellular Properties
,” J. Bone Joint Surg. Series A
, 88
(12
), pp. 2665
–2672
. 14.
Kummer
, F. J.
, and Iesaka
K.
, 2005, “The Role of Graft Materials in Suture Augmentation for Tendon Repairs and Reattachment
,” J. Biomed. Mat. Res. Part B App. Biomat.
, 74
(2
), pp. 789
–791
. 15.
Barber
, F. A.
, Herbert
, M. A.
, and Coons
D. A.
, 2006, “Tendon Augmentation Grafts: Biomechanical Failure Loads and Failure Patterns
,” Arthroscopy: J. Relat. Surg.
, 22
(5
), pp. 534
–538
. 16.
Awad
, H. A.
, Butler
, D. L.
, Boivin
, G. P.
, Smith
, F. N. L.
, Malaviya
, P.
, Huibregtse
, B.
, and Caplan
A. I.
, 1999, “Autologous Mesenchymal Stem Cell-Mediated Repair of Tendon
,” Tiss. Eng.
, 5
(3
), pp. 267
–277
. 17.
Awad
, H. A.
, Boivin
, G. P.
, Dressler
, M. R.
, Smith
, F. N. L.
, Young
, R. G.
, and Butler
, D. L.
, 2003, “Repair of Patellar Tendon Injuries Using a Cell-Collagen Composite
,” J. Orthop. Res.
, 21
(3
), pp. 420
–431
. 18.
Juncosa-Melvin
, N.
, Shearn
, J. T.
, Boivin
, G. P.
, Gooch
, C.
, Galloway
, M. T.
, West
, J. R.
, Nirmalanandhan
, V. S.
, Bradica
, G.
, and Butler
, D. L.
, 2006, “Effects of Mechanical Stimulation on the Biomechanics and Histology of Stem Cell-Collagen Sponge Constructs for Rabbit Patellar Tendon Repair
,” Tiss. Eng.
, 12
(8
), pp. 2291
–2300
. 19.
Shearn
, J. T.
, Juncosa-Melvin
, N.
, Boivin
, G. P.
, Galloway
, M. T.
, Goodwin
, W.
, Gooch
, C.
, Dunn
, M. G.
, and Butler
, D. L.
, 2007, “Mechanical Stimulation of Tendon Tissue Engineered Constructs: Effects on Construct Stiffness, Repair Biomechanics, and Their Correlation
,” ASME J. Biomech. Eng.
, 129
(6
), pp. 848
–854
. 20.
Juncosa-Melvin
, N.
, Matlin
, K. S.
, Holdcraft
, R. W.
, Nirmalanandhan
, V. S.
, and Butler
, D. L.
, 2007, “Mechanical Stimulation Increases Collagen type I and Collagen type III Gene Expression of Stem Cell-Collagen Sponge Constructs for Patellar Tendon Repair
,” Tiss. Eng.
, 13
(6
), pp. 1219
–1226
. 21.
Nirmalanandhan
, V. S.
, Juncosa-Melvin
, N.
, Shearn
, J. T.
, Boivin
, G. P.
, Galloway
, M. T.
, Gooch
, C.
, Bradica
, G.
, and Butler
, D. L.
, 2009, “Combined Effects of Scaffold Stiffening and Mechanical Preconditioning Cycles on Construct Biomechanics, Gene Expression, and Tendon Repair Biomechanics
,” Tiss. Eng. Part A
, 15
(8
), pp. 2103
–2111
. 22.
Juncosa-Melvin
, N.
, Boivin
, G. P.
, Gooch
, C.
, Galloway
, M. T.
, West
, J. R.
, Dunn
, M. G.
, and Butler
, D. L.
, 2006, “The Effect of Autologous Mesenchymal Stem Cells on the Biomechanics and Histology of Gel-Collagen Sponge Constructs Used for Rabbit Patellar Tendon Repair
,” Tiss. Eng.
, 12
(2
), pp. 369
–379
. 23.
Noyes
, F. R.
, DeLucas
, J. L.
, and Torvik
P. J.
, 1974, “Biomechanics of Anterior Cruciate Ligament Failure: An Analysis of Strain Rate Sensitivity and Mechanisms of Failure in Primates
,” J. Bone Joint Surg. Series A
, 56
(2
), pp. 236
–253
.24.
Butler
, D. L.
, Gooch
, C.
, Kinneberg
, K. R.
, Boivin
, G. P.
, Galloway
, M. T.
, Nirmalanandhan
, V. S.
, Shearn
, J. T.
, Dyment
, N. A.
, and Juncosa-Melvin
N.
, 2010, “The Use of Mesenchymal Stem Cells in Collagen-Based Scaffolds for Tissue-Engineered Repair of Tendons
,” Nat. Protoc.
, 5
(5
), pp. 849
–863
. 25.
Rodeo
, S. A.
, Arnoczky
, S. P.
, Torzilli
, P. A.
, Hidaka
, C.
, and Warren
, R. F.
, 1993, “Tendon-Healing in a Bone Tunnel. A Biomechanical and Histological Study in the Dog
,” J. Bone Joint Surg. Series A
, 75
(12
), pp. 1795
–1803
.26.
Wong
M. W. N.
, 2003, “Healing of Bone-Tendon Junction in a Bone Trough
,” Clin. Orthop.
, 413
, pp. 291
–302
. 27.
Gelberman
, R. H.
, Woo
, S. L.
, and Lothringer
K.
, 1982, “Effects of Early Intermittent Passive Mobilization on Healing Canine Flexor Tendons
,” J. Hand. Surg.
, 7
(2
), pp. 170
–175
.28.
Thomopoulos
, S.
, Williams
, G. R.
, and Soslowsky
L. J.
, 2003, “Tendon to Bone Healing: Differences in Biomechanical, Structural, and Compositional Properties due to a Range of Activity Levels
,” ASME J. Biomech. Eng.
, 125
(1
), pp. 106
–113
. 29.
Juncosa
, N.
, West
, J. R.
, Galloway
, M. T.
, Boivin
, G. P.
, and Butler
, D. L.
, 2003, “In Vivo Forces Used to Develop Design Parameters for Tissue Engineered Implants for Rabbit Patellar Tendon Repair
,” J. Biomech.
, 36
(4
), pp. 483
–488
. 30.
Malaviya
, P.
, Butler
, D. L.
, Korvick
, D. L.
, and Proch
, F. S.
, 1998, “In Vivo Tendon Forces Correlate with Activity Level and Remain Bounded: Evidence in a Rabbit Flexor Tendon Model
,” J. Biomech.
, 31
(11
), pp. 1043
–1049
. 31.
Amiel
, D.
, Frank
, C.
, and Harwood
F.
, 1984, “Tendons and Ligaments: A Morphological and Biochemical Comparison
,” J. Orthop. Res.
, 1
(3
), pp. 257
–265
. 32.
Amiel
, D.
, Kleiner
, J. B.
, and Roux
, R. D.
, 1986, “The Phenomenon of ‘Ligamentization’: Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction with Autogenous Patellar Tendon
,” J. Orthop. Res.
, 4
(2
), pp. 162
–172
. 33.
Scheffler
, S. U.
, Unterhauser
, F. N.
, and Weiler
, A.
, 2008, “Graft Remodeling and Ligamentization After Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction
,” Knee Surg. Sports Traumatol. Arthrosc.
, 16
(9
), pp. 834
–842
. 34.
Yamamoto
, E.
, Hayashi
, K.
, and Yamamoto
N.
, 1999, “Mechanical Properties of Collagen Fascicles from Stress-Shielded Patellar Tendons in the Rabbit
,” Clin. Biomech.
, 14
(6
), pp. 418
–425
. 35.
Yamamoto
, N.
, Ohno
, K.
, Hayashi
, K.
, Kuriyama
, H.
, Yasuda
, K.
, and Kaneda
K.
, 1993, “Effects of Stress Shielding on the Mechanical Properties of Rabbit Patellar Tendon
,” ASME J. Biomech. Eng.
, 115
(1
), pp. 23
–28
. 36.
Maeda
, E.
, Asanuma
, H.
, Noguchi
, H.
, Tohyama
, H.
, Yasuda
, K.
, and Hayashi
K.
, 2009, “Effects of Stress Shielding and Subsequent Restressing on Mechanical Properties of Regenerated and Residual Tissues in Rabbit Patellar Tendon After Resection of its Central One-Third
,” J. Biomech.
, 42
(11
), pp. 1592
–1597
. 37.
Maffulli
, N.
, King
J. B.
, 1992, “Effects of Physical Activity on Some Components of the Skeletal System
,” Sports Med.
, 13
(6
), pp. 393
–407
. 38.
Kannus
, P.
, Józsa
, L.
, Natri
, A.
, and Järvinen
M.
, 1997, “Effects of Training, Immobilization and Remobilization on Tendons
,” Scand. J. Med. Sci. Sports
, 7
(2
), pp. 67
–71
. 39.
Butler
, D. L.
, Grood
, E. S.
,Noyes
, F. R.
, Olmstead
, M. L.
, Hohn
, R. B.
, Arnoczky
, S. P.
, and Siegel
, M. G.
, 1989, “Mechanical Properties of Primate Vascularized vs. Nonvascularized Patellar Tendon Grafts; Changes Over Time
,” J. Orthop. Res.
, 7
(1
), pp. 68
–79
. 40.
Jackson
, D. W.
, Grood
, E. S.
, Goldstein
, J. D.
, Rosen
, M. A.
, Kurzweil
, P. R.
, Cummings
, J. F.
, and Simon
, T. M.
, 1993, “A Comparison of Patellar Tendon Autograft and Allograft used for Anterior Cruciate Ligament Reconstruction in the Goat Model
,” Am. J. Sports Med.
, 21
(2
), pp. 176
–185
. 41.
Ng
, G. Y. F.
, Oakes
, B. W.
, Deacon
, O. W.
, McLean
, I. D.
, and Eyre
, D. R.
, 1996, “Long-Term Study of the Biochemistry and Biomechanics of Anterior Cruciate Ligament-Patellar Tendon Autografts in Goats
,” J. Orthop. Res.
, 14
(6
), pp. 851
–856
. 42.
Miyashita
, H.
, Ochi
, M.
, and Ikuta
, Y.
, 1997, “Histological and Biomechanical Observations of the Rabbit Patellar Tendon After Removal of its Central One-Third
,” Arch. Orthop. Trauma Surg.
, 116
(8
), pp. 454
–462
. Copyright © 2011
by American Society of Mechanical Engineers
You do not currently have access to this content.
