0
Select Articles

Taking Engineering's Pulse PUBLIC ACCESS

Much of the Future for Mechanical Engineers Will Involve Integrating Systems of All Kinds, According to Participants in the M.E. Global Summit.

[+] Author Notes

Executive Editior

Mechanical Engineering 130(06), 36-39 (Jun 01, 2008) (4 pages) doi:10.1115/1.2008-JUN-3

Abstract

This article highlights key points of the Mechanical Engineering Global Summit. According to the participants, much of the future for mechanical engineers will involve integrating systems of all kinds. Throughout the discussions at the meeting, numerous comments concerned the increasingly interdisciplinary nature of engineering practice. Experts believe that vertical farms, for instance, could use hydroponics and other means to take farming indoors, where it could be carried out in multitiered structures. If technology like this could be made practical, it could multiply the area available for agriculture. A multibillion-dollar experiment in sustainable living has been proposed for the United Arab Emirates. The initiative hopes to create a high-tech city that will have zero emissions and be entirely self-sustaining. One of the proposals is to restructure engineering education and to prepare engineers the way lawyers and doctors are trained: a four-year liberal arts education in preparation for the professional degree in postgraduate study.

Article

If you assemble a group of engineersincluding men and women who have led professional societies or large engineering enterprises-and ask them about the future of mechanical engineering, they may talk about continuing globalization, or the need to address social and economic issues, or the implications of technology on ever smaller and larger scales. None of them expects the world to grow any simpler.

Many of the ideas that emerge can be described by the term "integrated systems," whether that means teams of people bringing a wide range of skills to bear on a single project, or collaborating with colleagues in distant time zones.

ASME has been asking engineers, in focus groups and polls, about the future. It also put the question to a meeting in April, the Global Summit on the Future of Mechanical Engineering, which brought together about 120 people from 18 countries to the National Academies building in Washington.

The Society's interest in sounding out its members and others in the profession is to get a bearing on where the organization should set its course for the future.

Much of the fu ture for mechanical engineers, as it is expected now, will involve integrating systems of all kinds. As Charles Vest, president of the National Academy of Engineering, sees it, the 20th century was the age of physics and electronics, typified by high-speed communications, for example, and transportation. The 21st will be the century of bio and info technology-of energy, water, sustainability, food, and other global concerns.

"Engineering is about systems," Vest told the participants in the Global Summit. As he explained it, the frontiers of engineering today are in tiny systems on the one hand, and in macro systems on the other.

At the very small scale, in bioengineering, information technology, and nanotechnology, there no longer will be a significant difference between scientist and engineer, Vest said. As they work closely together, their roles will not always be sharply distinguished.

Meanwhile, macro systems, involving solutions to issues '" of energy, environment, health care, manufacturing, communications, or logistics, will need contributions from areas far outside the traditional sphere of engineering. Solutions may need the additional perspective of social sciences, business management, and the humanities.

The activities at both extreme scales call for teams of people who will bring knowledge from different disciplines, and their contributions must be integrated into the final result.

Throughout the discussions at the meeting, numerous comments concerned the increasingly interdisciplinary nature of engineering practice. So much so that it drew a quick quip from the stage: The "M" in ASME is coming to stand for "multidisciplinary": "That will save us from having to redesign the letterhead."

Meanwhile, world population is currently more than 6 billion and growing. As Deborah Grubbe, vice president for group safety and industrial hygiene at BP Intenutional in London, pointed out, "Every year India creates another Australia."

In 20 years there could be more than 8 billion people sharing the planet.

Rohit Talwar, the chief executive of Fast Future, a consulting firm in London, said that taking people out of poverty is one place where engineering faces a challenge. "Life expectancy is growing," he said. "Where will people live?" What's more, how will they live?

Perhaps the world will see new technology, like some of the ideas that Talwar shared with the audience. Vertical farms, for instance, could use hydroponics and other means to take farming indoors, where it could be carried out in multitiered structures. If technology like this could be made practical, it could multiply the area available for agriculture.

A multi billion-dollar experiment in sustainable living has been proposed for the United Arab Emirates. The initiative hopes to create a high-tech city that will have zero emissions and be entirely self-sustaining. Engineers have been working to solve environmental and other challenges for some time. After all, enhancing the quality-or as some said, the joy-of life is what engineers do for a living.

In an attempt to get a sense of where the profession may be heading, ASME enlisted the services of the Institute for Alternative Futures, a not-for-profit research and educational organization that describes itself as working "with clients to create forecasts, scenarios, goals and strategies that are the essential tools for transforming organizations to succeed in times of rapid change."

IAF prepared a report, The Future of jV1echanical Engineering 2028, which it based on published reports and on focus group discussions and surveys of ASME members, to get a sense of the issues today that are expected to shape the profession of the future.

Based on its research, the organization identified a list of nine influences that it calls "drivers of change." They are.

  • Developing sustainability, as emerging economies compete for the world's resources.

  • Engineering at the extremes of large- and small-scale systems.

  • The competitive edge of knowledge, which will see demands for greater tec hnical knowledge and more depth in management, creativity, and problem solving.

  • The collaborative advantage, in which the dominant players will be organizations that are successful at working together.

  • Nanotechnology and biotechnology, which are expected to dominate technological development in the next 20 years.

  • R egulating global innova tion, to allow for both the increased sharing of knowledge and the protection of intellectual property.

  • The diverse face of engineering, par tly as a result of globalization and increased mobility.

  • Des igning at home, made poss ible by advances in computer-aided design, materials, and tools.

  • Engineering for the billions of people who live in poverty.

It was the first and last items on the list that resonated most strongly with engineers at the Global Summit.

Maria J esus Prieto-Laffargu e, president-elect of the World Federation of Engineering Organisations, spoke of "a new concept of society," one that will be marked by complexity and interdependence.

"Engineering stands out as the best system to address the challenges of the future: population growth, disparity in wealth, and the need for sustainable development," she said.

According to rAF 's report, "In 2028, the 10 largest economies in the world will include the rapidly developing economies of China, India, and Russia-followed closely behind by the fast growing economies of Brazil and Mexico. This rapid economic growth will add to global environm ental pressures and co mpetition for scarce resources. The mechanical engineering profession wi ll be challenged to develop new technologies and techniques that promote sustainability."

A represe ntative from C hina said that his co untry is working toward a more sustainable future and is taking steps to protect and restore its environment. Lu Yongxian, president of the China Academy of Sciences and of the Chinese Mec hanical Eng ineering Society, sa id, "New materials and knowledge push forward our manufa cturing to green manufacturing and services."

Among Lu's predi ctions for China in the future is an eventual " transition to an environment-friendly and sustainable energy system." Lu said that the Chinese government has recently taken steps for stronger monitoring and rehabilitation of lakes, rivers, streams, forests, grasslands, and wetland ecosystems.

According to Miguel Angel Yadarol a, president of the Pan Ameri ca n Academy of Engineering in Cordoba, Argentina, one impact of globalization will be " to pass from a national vision of the problems to an international vision."

Prieto-Laffargue sa id, "The world today is not divided by ideology, but by have and have-not technology."

G.K. Pillai, chairman and managing director of Heavy Equipment Corp. in Ranchi, India, said the challenges for engineering in the coming years are to develop means for "enhancing the joys of life, sustaining civilizations, and continuing advancement in spite of population growth."

In passing, Pillai disagreed with one of engineering's 14 grand challenges, a list published by the National Academy of Engineering this spring. He is not sure that the goal of securing cyberspace has much practical relevance in the world because so many people have no access to computers or to cyberspace that only a minority will benefit from it.

How to prepare the engineers who will shape the future was also a concern at the meeting. As James Duderstadt, president emeritus of the University of Michigan, pointed out, "In the United States, the engineering profession tends to be held in relatively low public esteem." Duderstadt is currently a professor of science and engineering at Mi.chigan. His comments were based on a report, Engineering for a Changing World, which he wrote for the university's Millennium Project, a think tank for new ideas about education.

One of his proposals is to restructure engineering education and to prepare engineers the way lawyers and doctors are trained: a four-year liberal arts education in preparation for the professional degree in postgraduate study. This could put engineering education on a par with the legal and medical professions, and also give students an opportunity for a wider range of learning than is possible to achieve in a four-year professional course of study.

He also proposes the establishment of Discovery Innovation Institutes, research centers supported by federal funding on university campuses. In his report, Duderstadt wrote, "These new centers would be created through a partnership, very much in the same spirit as the earlier land-grant acts, involving the federal government, the states, industry, and higher ed uca tion." The centers would carry out long-term research to convert scientific discoveries into the innovative technology "needed to sustain national prosperity and security in an increasingly competitive world."

Duderstadt's report is available on the Millennium Project Web si te at http://milproj.ummu.umich.edu/.

Yadarola suggested that schools reduce the number of specialties in undergraduate engineering programs to concentrate on "the nuin orientations." Specialty studies would be the subject of postgraduate education.

"The formation of an engineer tends to be more fragile the more specialized it is," he said.

Marc Goldsmith, an ASME Governor, addressed the assembly near the end of the meeting and seemed to sum up the spirit of the group. Engineers share a passion for their profession, he said, a passion for discovery and creation. "The world needs a lot more engineers," Goldsmith added, "if we are to make it a better and safer place to live."

Members of the summit (clockwise from top): Win Phillips, ASME past president and chair of the steering committee for the Global Summit; MarshaRhea of IAF (at board) and Bernard Hrubala, incoming ASME senior VP of Codes and Standards; James Duderstadt of the University of Michigan; Lu Yongxiang of the Chinese Academy of Sciences and V. Ismet Ugursal of Dalhousie University. At center is a vault in the Great Hall of the National Academies building.

Working on it: One of the breakout sessions during the global submit (right). Featured speakers included Sam Zamrik, ASME president (below); MariA Jesus Prieto-Laffargue of tha World Federation of Engineering Organization (bottom left); and G.K. Pillaj of Heavy Equipment Crop.

Grahic Jump LocationWorking on it: One of the breakout sessions during the global submit (right). Featured speakers included Sam Zamrik, ASME president (below); MariA Jesus Prieto-Laffargue of tha World Federation of Engineering Organization (bottom left); and G.K. Pillaj of Heavy Equipment Crop.

Looking to the Future(clockwise from upper left): Marc Goldsmith of ASME's Board of Governors; Harry Armen and Terry Shoup, ASME past presidents; Deborah Grubbe of BP International; and Charles Vest of the NAE.

Grahic Jump LocationLooking to the Future(clockwise from upper left): Marc Goldsmith of ASME's Board of Governors; Harry Armen and Terry Shoup, ASME past presidents; Deborah Grubbe of BP International; and Charles Vest of the NAE.

Copyright © 2008 by ASME
View article in PDF format.

References

Figures

Tables

Errata

Discussions

Some tools below are only available to our subscribers or users with an online account.

Related Content

Customize your page view by dragging and repositioning the boxes below.

Related Journal Articles
Related eBook Content
Topic Collections

Sorry! You do not have access to this content. For assistance or to subscribe, please contact us:

  • TELEPHONE: 1-800-843-2763 (Toll-free in the USA)
  • EMAIL: asmedigitalcollection@asme.org
Sign In